PR agency spamming bloggers - take 2#

The other day I posted about how some bloggers are reacting by blocking e-mail pitches from some PR agencies.

I mentioned Todd Defren who had found his agency had fallen foul of a blogger blocking them along with many other agencies big and small. A sort of one strike and you are out rule. Ouch!

Todd left a comment on my post that I have not responded to yet. Sorry Tom. I will. In it Tom mentioned that one reason he felt the blocking was unfair was that the 'do not pitch/private' e-mail address of the blogger was in fact published as the contact address by a directory listing service. In this post by Kami Huyse she confirms the point Todd made and adds some additional thoughts of her own about the subject and how it can be resolved satisfactorily for all sides.

One of the challenges in PR terms as I mentioned in my earlier post is volume versus customisation and targeting of messages. A client tends to expect to see results based upon a volume metric. I know I did when I was a Marketing Director in industry. It just did not feel right to be targeting less than what we could. All other communication is measured by a mix of 'reach and volume' and response volumes. Will clients pay for agencies to invest the time and resources to check every blogger before contacting them? Does the campaign deadlines allow the time? Equally is it fair to expect bloggers to receive generic and largely untargeted press releases?

I don't think there is an easy answer except for PR agencies to keep trying their best to target what they can and push back on clients when either time or client expectations do not match what needs to be done.

5/14/2008 10:38:28 PM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00) #    Add to del.icio.us Add to digg Comments [2]  |  Trackback

 

5/15/2008 3:59:30 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
The balance here is very difficult and I think that you make a great point by brining in the client expectation for volume. My question is, do they want volume of output, or volume of results? Another question, is the widespread spamming of pitches actually working? If so, how do we fight that battle?

I think that it probably isn't working and that we as PR professionals are learning a new skill which has more to do with fanning flames than starting fires.
5/15/2008 7:16:13 AM (GMT Daylight Time, UTC+01:00)
Kami,

Good points. I bet most CxOs would say both or at least they are used to volume of results being a % of volume of output. The knee-jerk link is that the greater the mailing volume the higher the volume of results. It becomes a numbers game. With list fatigue and declining % response the pressure is on to increase volume even more. Another factor is ROI on time and cost. Let me stay with DM for a while. At what point does the cost of list analysis and segmentation (plus time) and testing exceed the costs and effort of 'post and be dammed?'. At what point does the final 'A' of AIDA kick-in? 3rd, 4th or more mailing? For some 'spray a pitch' PR could be business as usual. The problem for PR is that in the old days journalists would just bin/delete badly targeted 'pitches' and possibly 'block' further stuff from the agency/company quietly. Bloggers can and do bite back - publicly. Blocked pitches becomes a real risk.

As you say we need new skills and techniques to address this. We also need to be prepared to argue for the time and budget from clients to do it properly.



Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (HTML not allowed)  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

All content © 2008, Adrian Moss
Blogroll
Calendar
<October 2008>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2829301234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930311
2345678
Archives
Sitemap
 
 3M
 ABC News
 Ads
 AdWeek
 Age Discrimination
 Age Regulations 2006
 All Blacks
 American Express
 Amputees in Action
 anti-social behaviour
 Apple
 Australia
 BA
 Badgers
 Barclays
 BBC
 BBC iPlayer
 BEA
 Ben & Jerry's
 Blog Council
 Blogging
 Blogosphere
 BOTTLE PR
 Bourbon Dolphin
 Brands
 Brands2life
 Brian Solis
 broadband
 Brodeur
 Budget 2008
 Burma
 Business Week
 BuzzLogic
 Cadbury's
 Cadence
 Car Phone Warehouse
 Casualties Union
 CEO blogs
 Charles Leadbetter
 China
 Chrysler
 CIPR
 Cisco
 Citizen Journalism
 Citizen police
 City Link
 Club Penguin
 Coca Cola
 Colin Byrne
 Commmoncraft
 community marketing
 Company of Information Technologists
 Comparitive Media Studies
 Conde Nast
 Consumer Generated Content
 Conversational marketing
 Corporate Communications
 country living
 Crisis
 Crisis management
 Crowdsourcing
 Customer Engagement
 Customer Relationships
 Data Portability Workgroup
 Data privacy
 Debbie Weil
 Dell
 Depression
 DG SANCO
 Digital marketing
 Disney
 Don Pepper
 Dr Martha Rogers
 Ebbsfleet United
 Echo Chamber
 Edelman
 Eden Project
 Edinburgh Festival
 Employee Communications
 Employee Engagement
 EPA
 EUFIC
 European Podcast Summit 2007
 facebook
 Fake blogging
 Fat Face
 Federated Media
 Financial Times
 Fishburn Hedges
 Flickr
 Flouridation
 Forrester Research
 Fred Reichheld
 Gareth Morgan
 Gartner
 Ghost blogs
 GM
 GM Europe
 Google
 Google AdSense
 Groundswell Awards
 Guardian Unlimited
 Heather Gorringe
 Heinz
 Henry Jenkins
 HitWise
 Hotel industry
 HP
 HPA
 HSBC
 Hugh MacLeod
 Hugh McLeod
 Human behaviour
 IBM
 IM
 Indiana Jones
 Influencers
 Institute of Direct Marketing
 Intel
 internet
 internet video
 IPA
 iPM
 iPod
 IPPR
 Jamie Oliver
 Jeff Jarvis
 Jennifer Cisney
 Jennifer Jones
 Jeremiah Owyang
 Jeremiha Owyang
 John Chambers
 Johnson & Johnson
 Jonathan Schwartz
 Josephine Wills
 Joyce Lewis
 kalymnos
 Kami Huyse
 KD Paine
 Kelloggs
 Kettle
 kodak
 Leadership development
 Learning and development
 Lego
 Levi
 Lifejackets
 LinkedIn
 Littlewoods
 London Social Media Cafe
 Long tail
 Lotus
 management development
 Marcel Mauss
 Maritime and Coastguard Agency
 Market research
 Marketing Improvement Europe
 Marriott Hotels
 Marshall McLuhan
 Martha Stewart
 Mash-Ups
 MCA
 McDonalds
 Measurement
 MeasurementCamp 08
 Metrics
 Microsoft
 Mike Arrington
 Mike Butcher
 Mobile advertising
 Monty Python
 MSC Napoili
 myspace
 NBC
 Net Promoter Score
 neuroscience
 Neville Hobson
 New media
 NHS
 Nielsen Online
 Nokia
 NUJ
 Number 10
 Ofcom
 Online advertising
 Online Communities
 Online Communities
 Online newspapers/magazines
 Online video
 Open Social
 P&G
 Paul Gillin
 Personal
 Personal thoughts
 Peter Day
 Pluck
 podcast
 podcasts
 Poundland
 PR 2.0
 PR measurement
 PR Week
 Presentation skills
 press release
 Primark
 Prime Minister
 Prof Andrew McAfee
 Prof. Wesch
 Quark
 Radian6
 Reebok
 Rentokil
 Reuters
 Richard Binhammer
 Richard Sambrook
 Robert Madelin
 Robert Scoble
 ROI measurement
 Rummble
 SAP
 Satmetrix
 Second Life
 seesmic
 Seesmic
 SEO
 Service Industries
 Seth Godin
 sharedband
 Shel Holtz
 Shel Israel
 Small World Experiments
 Social media
 Social Media Release
 social networking
 Sony
 South Central NHS
 Southampton
 Southampton Boat Show
 SouthWest Airlines
 St Barts Church
 Starbucks